F1 Season 2006 Review

SpeedAlonsoSchuIde

An in-depth look at the past season, team by team and driver by driver

Back to
Reject CENTRALE
Back to
Main Page
Go to
Text-Only Version
Season Overview  |  "Reject of the Year"  |  Season Review Podcast

Here are our reviews for the season, ranked here according to a rating out of 10 awarded by us. For both drivers and teams, we have taken into consideration their equipment, past form, luck (or lack thereof) and our initial expectations for 2006.
TEAMS
TOP 13 DRIVERS
DRIVERS 14-27
1. Renault
2. Ferrari
3. BMW Sauber
4. Super Aguri Honda
5. Honda
6. McLaren Mercedes
7. Toro Rosso Cosworth
8. Toyota
9. MF1 Toyota
10. Red Bull Ferrari
11. Williams Cosworth
1. Fernando Alonso
2. Michael Schumacher
3. Kimi Raikkonen
4. Jenson Button
5. Felipe Massa
6. Mark Webber
7: Robert Kubica
8: Takuma Sato
9. Giancarlo Fisichella
10. Nick Heidfeld
11: Nico Rosberg
12: Pedro de la Rosa
13. Jacques Villeneuve
14. Ralf Schumacher
15. Jarno Trulli
16. Scott Speed
17: Vitantonio Liuzzi
18. David Coulthard
19. Christijan Albers
20. Christian Klien
21. Franck Montagny
22. Robert Doornbos
23. Juan Pablo Montoya
24. Rubens Barrichello
25. Sakon Yamamoto
26. Yuji Ide
27. Tiago Monteiro

Season 2006 Overview
There is a sense of nostalgia which is sure to hang over the 2006 Formula One season - if it hasn't begun to do so already - such that we will all look back on it with rose-tinted glasses sooner rather than later. And, in many ways, so it should be. Here, finally, was a genuine championship battle between two drivers from different generations, both at the absolute top of their game and with their respective teams likewise. It had been decades since we had seen anything like it.

It was also dramatic, a classic season of two halves. Fernando Alonso skipped away in the first part of the year in irrepressible fashion. But then came the Ferrari resurgence, and Michael Schumacher's chase, which featured several awesome races, most notably Hungary, China and Brazil. And to top it off came the reality of Schumi's impending retirement; here was the prospect of this colossus of the sport, striding its arena for the last time, and walking away with its greatest prize for the eighth time. It was not to be.

But to label it a season of two halves, though it may have appeared that way, would be to undersell the achievements and the year-long efforts of both these drivers and their teams. Alonso's incredible consistency on the racetrack made him a worthy successor to Schumacher as the best, most relentless driver in the world; in terms of regular error-free performance, the Spaniard may have even surpassed the German legend. After all, he beat Michael in a straight fight to become the youngest-ever double champion.

And this was a Schumacher who showed all throughout the year, and not just in the second half of it, that he still had it all. By that I mean that he still had the hunger, he still had the speed, he still had the greatest skill overall, but he still had that occasional mistake, and he still had the controversy. All season long, from the opening salvos in Bahrain to the last hurrah in Brazil, there was very little to choose between the reliability and performance of the Renault/Michelin and the Ferrari/Bridgestone packages.

Having said that, the performance levels of Renault and Ferrari were also undoubtedly magnified by the fact that so many other drivers and their teams had such middling seasons that fell below their pre-season expectations. McLaren went from having the fastest car of 2005 to their first winless year since 1996, and had the disruption of Juan-Pablo Montoya leaving mid-season. Honda's pre-season speed was never replicated despite Jenson Button's maiden win and a vast overall improvement on last year.

The Class of 2006 pose in BrazilThe scandal of 2006: Monaco-gate
Red Bull, surprise packet regular points scorers in 2005, were just about looking towards 2007 before the 2006 season even began. Toyota showed that whenever they take two steps forward, they take one big step back. And hardly any story throughout 2006 could have been more sobering than the unmitigated implosion by Williams, race after race like a recurring nightmare. It all made the job of ranking for this review the 11 teams and the 27 drivers who raced, a very difficult one indeed.

The drama of the season was also aided by what seemed to be rather conspicuous meddling by officialdom in the second half of the year. There was the mass dampers affair that hit Renault at the most inconvenient time, Alonso's qualifying penalty in Hungary, not to mention the ludicrous penalty meted out to the Spaniard after qualifying at Monza. Even if it was all purely and innocently coincidental, it did nothing to quieten the growing number of cynics out there.

Politically it was a comparatively quiet year. The new qualifying system worked a treat. V8 engines meant slower straight-line speeds, but aero advances and the tyre war meant corner speeds increased and lap times changed little. The return of tyre changes was not universally popular but it did even things up between Bridgestone and Michelin. The Grand Prix Manufacturers' Association died a slow death, and the rules for 2008 and the debate over engine freezing were often the topics of the day. Hear the snoring?

Compared to last year, surprises were also few and far between. Prodrive won the right to be the 12th team in 2008, the defection of Alonso to McLaren for 2007 was old news, and Michelin's withdrawal at the end of the year was not unexpected. There were no new tracks this year, no major team buy-outs apart from Spyker taking over from Midland, and there was no rookie who managed to impress with any regularity. Only Montoya's move to NASCAR proved a shock, but to many that was just surreally absurd.

So overall, a very good year, one which many will look back on fondly, but in truth not outstanding. Renault, Ferrari, Alonso and Schumacher were undeniably brilliant, but their performance was highlighted by the ordinariness of their rivals - so much so that we have broken from tradition to base our 'Reject of the Year' podium positions on not just the driver rankings - and by the lack of intrigue elsewhere in the paddock. The best separated from the rest and fighting it out - some will say that that's how it ought to be.

Back to the top.


"Reject of the Year" Award
3rd place
Juan Pablo Montoya

Although he did put in a number of solid points-scoring performances, his moments of sheer daftness in Australia, Spain, Canada and America were bewildering. And then he promptly left for NASCAR of all places! Reject material if ever we heard it...

JPM
2nd place
Yuji Ide

With one good FNippon season in 05 behind him, and barely a shakedown to speak of before debuting along with his brand new team at Bahrain, poor Yuji faced a baptism of fire. But we still didn't expect what we saw. In short, he was the least impressive F1 driver in a decade.

Ide
1st place
Williams Cosworth

A double-retirement at Sepang signalled the beginning of a 10-race point-less catastrophe: hydraulics, engines, gearboxes, exhausts, throttles, tyres, halfshafts and electrics all failed during races, while five collisions and other driving errors added to the DNF litany. Sir Frank's nightmare is our RotY!

Williams


F1 Rejects
Back to Reject CENTRALE
Main Page   |    Drivers Index   |   Reject Teams   |   Hall of Shame
Reject Extras
Reject Interviews
Submit-a-Reject
FAQ / Copyright
Reject CENTRALE
• Latest GP Review
• Other Articles
• Links / Banner
Sign Guestbook
Read Guestbook
Current Poll
Previous Polls
All original content Copyright © 2006 Formula One Rejects.