|
2009 Top 13 Drivers Review
An in-depth look at the past season, team by team and driver by driver |
||||
| Back to 2009 Season Review | Back to Reject CENTRALE | Go to Text-Only Version | ||
|
||||
| 1. Jenson Button | ||||||
|
||||||
|
Brawn's fairytale was also Jenson Button's Cinderella story. He goes from the basement of 'Reject of the Year' in 2008 to the penthouse of World Championship glory, gets our number one ranking this year and an MBE from the Queen. It goes without saying that he set up his year with four poles and six wins from the first seven races. That streak included some outrageously good moments, including his pole lap at Monaco and his relentless race pace in Bahrain, Spain and Turkey, all of which were laced with the self-assuredness of the greats.
That same self-confidence disappeared when the Brawn's tyre temperature issues appeared, and his qualifying thereafter was the weakest element of his season. Instead of driving with flair, he kept gritting and forcing his way to points finishes, and Belgium was the only time he missed out whilst no-one was able to challenge him consistently. Along the way his passing manoeuvres, especially in Brazil, quickly went into folklore. Anyone who said he didn't deserve the championship were kidding themselves.
|
||||||
|
||||||
| 2. Lewis Hamilton | ||||||
|
||||||
|
5th place and 49 points was Hamilton's lowest place and points haul in his F1 career, and exactly half the points he scored in his championship-winning 2008, but it was arguably his best season to date. Without the advantage and the associated arrogance of a race-winning car, and after his fantastic 4th place in Melbourne was stripped away thanks to the unscrupulous attempt to blindside the stewards, Lewis realised he had to work for his results and adopt a more humble attitude in so doing. He succeeded in both areas.
The result was another 4th place in Bahrain in a car that had no right to up that high, and when the McLaren finally started coming good he was ready to exploit it, especially since he was the best exponent of KERS. He won by passing Webber on track in Hungary and by dominating Singapore, took four poles, and fought to the death on his two-stop strategy at Monza. His last lap crash there showed that mistakes were still a part of his game, following his Q1 accident at Monaco and his over-brave start in Germany.
|
||||||
|
||||||
| 3. Sebastian Vettel | ||||||
|
||||||
|
There was hardly a more impressive sight in 2009 than Sebastian Vettel in full flight. When Webber pulled off something special, you admired the bravery and effort. When Vettel did something other-worldly, you knew you were watching evolving genius. That was the difference between them. Take, for example, the stunning qualifying laps in China and Japan and his complete supremacy in both races, and also his sheer dominance from the front in Britain, and once he got to the lead in Abu Dhabi.
Or consider the blinding laps just before pit stops in Bahrain, Germany, Belgium and Brazil that leapt him up the field. All whilst retaining a cheerful and friendly demeanour that made him impossible to dislike. But if he has any burning ambition beneath, which he does, he should know that he ought to have been the champion. Poor starts in Bahrain, Spain, Germany and Hungary which hurt his strategy, and errors in Australia, Malaysia, Monaco, Turkey all cost him points that determined the fate of the title.
|
||||||
|
||||||
| 4. Mark Webber | ||||||
|
||||||
|
Sebastian Vettel may have ended up 14.5 points ahead of Webber, but really there was little to split the Red Bull pair. Webber may have been out-qualified by his team-mate 15 to 2, smashing his qualifying aura, but his worst mishaps, in qualifying in Australia, Bahrain and Britain, and in practice at Suzuka, were pre-race. When it mattered on Sundays, he often had the better of Vettel. In Malaysia, Monaco and Hungary, for instance, he was the one scoring points whilst Sebastian had thrown it away.
He was the one pulling off the mega passing moves on Button in China and on Alonso in Spain, and delivering the awesome middle stints in Spain and Turkey. He was the one who dominated at the Nurburgring despite a drive-through penalty, and who took a commanding win in Brazil as well. The five scoreless races from Valencia to Japan that destroyed his title momentum was more the team's fault than his. And Mark did all this carrying an injury. But ultimately, you felt Vettel comfortably had more pace in reserve.
|
||||||
|
||||||
| 5. Rubens Barrichello | ||||||
|
||||||
|
This ranking is really by process of elimination. You couldn't rank any lower a man who scored points in 15 out of 17 races, who took two convincing victories at Valencia and Monza (the latter in a straight fight against the eventual champion), and who was in the title hunt right up to Brazil. But at the same time, at no stage did Rubens have any real moments of greatness. The truth is, Rubens was comprehensively out-driven by Button in the first seven races of the year which ultimately determined the championship result.
Barrichello never really came to terms with that, or with the poor strategy calls that hurt him at Barcelona and the Nurburgring. His whingeing in Turkey and Germany did nothing to endear him either. And although he became Brawn's lead driver from Britain onwards in terms of regular pace, it was more a case of his performance level remaining steady whilst Button's dropped, and yet Jenson still beat him home in five of those ten events. All in all, it was a pleasant Indian summer for the Brazilian, but little more than that.
|
||||||
|
||||||
| 6. Nico Rosberg | ||||||
|
||||||
|
Rosberg's consistency in 2009 was the sign of a driver who had matured and was ready for the next level. With 14 appearances in Q3, only Barrichello and the Red Bull drivers appeared in the last segment of qualifying more times. With 11 points-scoring results, only Vettel and the Brawn drivers recorded more. All of Nico's points finishes were in the region from 4th to 8th, including a run of eight in a row from Spain to Belgium, which was instrumental in driving and keeping up Williams' momentum throughout the year.
But whether Nico was becoming a Barrichello-like solid operator, or a driver capable of greatness, was yet to be clarified. The naysayers will point to Melbourne, where the drop-off in his pace on the option tyres was one of the most notable examples of poor tyre management all year. Or to Malaysia, where the lead in the first stint was given up meekly in a single out lap. Or to Singapore, where a sure 2nd and a possible win was thrown away by a rookie's mistake. The platform is there, but where does it lead?
|
||||||
|
||||||
| 7. Kimi Raikkonen | ||||||
|
||||||
|
In our season preview, we said that 2009 would be a test of Kimi's reputation and motivation. How true that turned out to be. In the first half of the season, it was easy to make the "coke and ice cream" jokes (and we did). Although he was more consistent than Massa in qualifying, and although he scored Ferrari's first points in Bahrain and first front row and podium in Monaco, when Felipe was putting in some sparkling drives in mid-season, The Iceman was being left in the shade. In all, Felipe out-qualified him 6 to 4.
But after Massa's accident in Hungary, and Raikkonen had to step up as team leader, as well as to prove his worth to his team and the paddock at large, Kimi was excellent. Four straight podiums in Hungary, Valencia, Belgium and Italy, including his traditional Spa brilliance when Fisichella was quicker, stamped an indelible mark. After ten fastest laps in 2008, in 2009 Kimi had none, which meant he was eking out the results in an inferior car. Would probably have been ranked below Massa, though, if Felipe had a full season.
|
||||||
|
||||||
| 8. Fernando Alonso | ||||||
|
||||||
|
There was no doubt that Alonso extracted as much out of the Renault R29 as humanly possible, even if he did not exceed the car on as many occasions as he could, such was his understandable frustration that after the improvement shown in late-2008, the team dished up such mediocrity on and off the track this season. He only missed Q3 five times which told of his enormous inherent ability, and when the team went really aggressive with strategy, as in China and Hungary, he planted his car on the front row.
Often, though - nine times to be precise - he started in the fourth or fifth rows, and not necessarily with a heavy fuel load, which meant that he was scrapping for minor points and vulnerable to rivals running long from just outside the top ten. In the circumstances, eight points finishes was a commendable effort, with the two major highlights being a superb marathon middle stint in Germany and the podium in Singapore which lifted the team's spirits. But was there any doubt that he would be Ferrari-bound in 2010?
|
||||||
|
||||||
| 9. Felipe Massa | ||||||
![]()
|
||||||
|
This ranking simply reflects the fact that Felipe's season was sadly curtailed and we never got to see how he would have gone in the last seven races. Up to that point, his season fell into two distinct segments. After his championship near-miss in 2008, the first four races saw much effort for zero reward, as Felipe faced the reality that the F60 was not only troublesome but simply not a title contender, and his panicking team made bizarre errors like the backfiring Q1 gamble in Malaysia.
But once the Ferrari started to improve a little bit, and Massa came to terms with the fact that he had to make the best of an average situation, his form picked up markedly. He staved off Vettel bravely in Spain and should have been 4th, his exceptional middle stints at Monaco and Silverstone did indeed net 4th places, and he was finally rewarded with a podium at the Nurburgring. At that point he had 22 points to Raikkonen's 10. Given how much Raikkonen impressed thereafter, what could Felipe have done?
|
||||||
|
||||||
| 10. Sebastien Buemi | ||||||
|
||||||
|
A top-ten ranking for Buemi reflects the low expectations just about everyone held for the Swiss rookie when the season began, and how much Sebastien caught the eye as his season progressed. Advancing to Q2 and scoring points on debut was surprising enough, but qualifying 10th and starring in the wet in China left even the most cynical observers impressed. Then came the inevitable dip including his collisions with Bourdais and Piquet in Spain and Monaco respectively, but he had made it to Q2 in both those events as well.
In all, Buemi out-qualified Bourdais 7 to 2, and had a perfect 8-0 record over Alguersuari, making Q2 nine times and Q3 on four occasions. He rode out the middle part of the year when the Toro Rosso was uncompetitive, but when the upgrade package arrived for Hungary his form picked up again, culminating in the last three races of the year. At Suzuka his raw pace was staggering, whilst in Brazil and Abu Dhabi his mature drives to points suggested that his rough edges were being refined, and fast.
|
||||||
|
||||||
| 11. Nick Heidfeld | ||||||
|
||||||
|
If your life depended on someone to drive at eleven tenths, or pull out a mega lap, or deliver something special, Nick Heidfeld is not your man. Although he finished 2nd in the rain-shortened Sepang race, that was thanks largely to a tyre gamble at just the right moment. Otherwise, he did not really produce anything that you would class as a special drive, like team-mate Kubica's efforts in Australia and Brazil. Mind you, the man from Munchengladbach has produced nothing of the sort ... in living memory.
What you do know you're going to get is nothing less than an honest, consistent effort, which contrasted with Kubica's fluctuations this year. Kubica may have had higher highs, but also lower lows. Nick's run of 41 classified finishes was finally snapped by a reckless Sutil in Singapore. In the six races from Monaco to Valencia, Heidfeld finished 11th four times and 10th once, reflecting exactly where his car was at, as did his four points-scoring finishes in the last six races. He was a perfect gauge of where his BMW stood.
|
||||||
|
||||||
| 12. Jarno Trulli | ||||||
|
||||||
|
There was some similarity in the way that Trulli and Glock's seasons went, but Jarno had more peaks than his team-mate, and did not have as extended a run of mediocrity as Timo did. The Italian also had a clear edge in qualifying, winning the intra-team qualifying battle against his team-mates (both Glock and Kobayashi) 13-4, appearing in Q3 eleven times, taking pole in Bahrain and recording front-row starts in Belgium and Japan, even if his reputation as the qualifying king seemed to fade somewhat.
Although his drives in Australia and Japan were right out of the top drawer, and he made the best of the situation in Bahrain, out of his eight points-scoring races he never had more than two in a row, which underscored an inconsistency that we had not seen for several years. He also got caught up in a rather high number of incidents for a driver of his experience, and the way he behaved after his clash with Sutil in Brazil was not only ugly, but seemed like the actions of a grumpy old man starting to go on the wane.
|
||||||
|
||||||
|
Some images used here are Copyright © Formula1.com and GPUpdate.net. Most are taken from the websites of the various teams and drivers. For enlarged versions, please visit their sites! |
||||||
| |||
| Back to 2009 Season Review | |||
| Main Page | Drivers Index | Reject Teams | Hall of Shame | |||
|
Reject Extras Reject Interviews Submit-a-Reject FAQ / Copyright |
Reject CENTRALE Latest GP Review Other Articles Links / Banner |
Sign Guestbook Read Guestbook Current Poll Previous Polls |
|
|
|
|||
| All original content Copyright © 1999-2009 Formula One Rejects. | |||