|
Pride or Prejudiced? Michael Andretti's 1993
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
| Back to Reject CENTRALE | Back to Main Page | Go to Text-Only Version | ||||||||||||||||||||
The stereotypical answers are well-known. Andretti's team-mate and immediate yardstick was Ayrton Senna, the most difficult challenge imaginable. The brute turbo Indycar was oceans apart from the gizmo-laden 1993-spec McLaren, in the same kind of gulf that destroyed Alessandro Zanardi when the Italian returned to F1 from CART in 1999. Plus there was Michael's decision to keep living in Pennsylvania during the season. But of course, in F1 nothing is ever quite so black and white. Though these were indeed the key factors, the surrounding details deserve to be told in full. The early 1990s were a period of unprecedented F1 interest in North American drivers. CART was in its big-name heyday, and apart from just Andretti, Williams showed interest in Al Unser, Jr. and Benetton in Paul Tracy. There always seemed an air of destiny, however, that Michael would follow in his father's footsteps and progress to F1, whereas 'Little Al' or Tracy basically did not have Grand Prix racing in their bloodlines. Mario also had the contacts in F1 to make it happen, and in Tyler Alexander at McLaren, Michael had a family friend who could provide a link to one of the best teams around.
The contact led to an initial test for Andretti at Estoril in early 1991, at the start of his championship year in CART. It was an inconclusive dabble, with Michael only managing 12 laps, just four of which were in the dry. But it was enough for Ron Dennis to sign the American to a 'testing contract', which was more a case of the team keeping an option over him and monitoring his progress than actually giving him more track time. As it was, for the rest of the year Andretti only managed one more test, in the middle of the year at Magny-Cours. That was all the F1 experience Michael had until September 1992, when Dennis flew to Detroit to meet him. Ron was in a quandary; he was losing Honda engines at the end of the year, as well as Gerhard Berger to Ferrari. In addition, it was clear that Senna had eyes for Williams, which was in the process of destroying all comers that year. Andretti, meanwhile, had not managed to defend his 1991 CART crown, but he was a consistent enough performer to show that he was the real deal. Dennis came away having signed him for 1993, with an option for two further years. "I think he can win Grands Prix," Dennis said afterwards, "and in the process of winning those GPs he can become the World Champion. It's not a question of which country you come from. It's how best you demonstrate that desire to win. You've got to have that desire to win, and the aggression in traffic. And there are probably fewer than five drivers in the world that I consider to have the necessary aggression." That was the attraction for McLaren, but what was the lure for Andretti? Quite simply, Dennis had told him that he was 90% sure of securing the all-conquering Renault engines for 1993. For Michael, it seemed like an opportunity to jump into F1 in competitive machinery and be in the fight for points, podiums and victories straight away. But in a short space of time, a sequence of events and decisions would stack the odds firmly against him. In October 1992, the FIA ruled that for the following year, in-season testing would be limited to a track in the team's home country. There would also be a limit to the number of tyres available during race weekends, as well as limits to the number of practice laps a driver could do. Learning tracks would be a greater challenge than first thought.
Then the Renault engine deal, which may have been true or may also have simply been a bargaining tool, evaporated. With no other readily available options, McLaren had to sign a Ford customer deal for 1993, giving them second billing after Ford's works agreement with Benetton. Andretti joined the team in December 1992 for initial tests at Barcelona and at Paul Ricard with leftover Honda V12s, but when the Ford customer V8s were finally installed, they were some 30 to 40 horsepower down on the motors in the Benettons, and at least 60 to 80 horsepower down on the rampant Renault V10s. The electronics were also shaping up to be a source of concern. Not only did Michael have to get used to the concepts of active suspension, traction control and semi-automatic gearboxes, features completely foreign someone used to passively-suspended Lolas with manual gearshifts, but McLaren also chose to honour their long-standing relationship with TAG rather than change to Ford's own electronics systems. Getting the TAG software to synchronise properly with the Ford V8 would be an ongoing issue throughout the season. And who would be Andretti's team-mate? Stung by a comparatively uncompetitive 1992, Senna did not want to be put in the same position again, but his arch-nemesis Alain Prost had signed for Williams and there was no way Ayrton could go there. He played an incredible game of brinkmanship with Dennis throughout the winter and the first half of the 1993 season, committing only on a race-to-race basis. So in January 1993, Dennis signed Mika Hakkinen as a back-up. If Senna chose to drive, the Flying Finn would test. If Senna did not, Hakkinen was ready to fill the breach. Not only was the uncertainty unsettling, but in hindsight it created a highly-charged, highly-competitive atmosphere within the team that did Michael no favours. If Senna did not race, then Andretti would be up against a hard-charging talent desperate to prove himself in a leading car. But as it turned out, Ayrton chose to compete and Andretti found himself paired with the very best in the business. That also meant Hakkinen remained lurking in the background, and if Michael faltered in any way, there was a ready-made replacement. The pressure was on.
At a test in February 1993, Andretti was hampered badly by constant electronic gremlins. He went back to the States, while Hakkinen got into the car just as the problems sorted themselves out, and Mika was able to get significant miles behind him. Had Michael relocated to England, it is conceivable that McLaren would have changed their program and put Andretti back into the car for more experience. Of all the things that went wrong for the American, this was completely self-inflicted. What made Michael decide to keep living in the USA? Pride? Naivety? The answer was probably a mixture of the two. On being asked about where he would live soon after he was signed, he said, "Hopefully, I'll be able to do it without living [in Europe]. I think it's very important to have a home to go home to." Mario had managed to commute during much of his F1 career, so why couldn't Michael do the same? Mario supported his son's choice: "All he needs is one or two tests. He doesn't need to grind away. Michael's not a test driver like some of those other guys, you know, there to do the donkey testing. He's there to go for it." For a start, Mario was also committed to a full US racing program for some of the years he was doing F1, which necessitated remaining in Pennsylvania. Secondly, the job description of a Grand Prix driver had changed since Mario's day. Gone was the era when a driver could simply breeze in, drive the wheels off the car, and walk away with a result. From the 1990s onwards, an F1 driver needed the time in the car and the time spent with the team, both to familiarise himself with, and get the best out of, the ever-more nuanced beast that was a Grand Prix car, as well as for the sake of team morale. Michael made it clear that, if the team wanted him to test, he was a phone call and a six-hour flight away. That, he thought, was commitment to the cause. In the eyes of the team and its mechanics though, a six-hour flight and accompanying jetlag was very different to someone who was half an hour's drive away, and who would drop in at the factory from time to time. That, they thought, was commitment and team spirit. Michael dropping in on race weekends was akin to arrogance. Alexander told Michael that he should live in England and visit the factory a few times a week.
Andretti just didn't get it. And then there was his then-wife Sandy, who by all accounts very quickly made herself a nuisance within the squad. Used to the all-access, big-stars-and-trappings approach of American motorsport, she asked for not only pit passes but also headphones to listen in on her man when he was in the car. This was a completely unprecedented request in the world of the F1 paddock, a closely-guarded sanctum where access is limited, where rights are on a needs-must basis only, and where partners and wives stand unobtrusively looking worried but never actually get involved. Perhaps it was not only just a case of Sandy being over-anxious for her husband, but also a fact that she liked the limelight herself. Her outfits, more suited to a day at the Kentucky Derby than the F1 pits, attracted disdain. Despite her eventual divorce from Michael, the way she swooned over son Marco in front of the media scrum after he came within metres of winning the Indy 500 as a rookie perhaps gives an insight into her personality. Legend has it that Dennis especially employed someone to take her shopping to get her out of the way on race weekends. Against the backdrop of all these factors, Michael was up against it, and right from the word go the results showed. After first qualifying at the season opener in South Africa, Andretti was 6th fastest with expected room for improvement. But then software problems affecting the active suspension appeared, not for the last time, before an engine failure on Saturday left him 9th on the grid on debut. That did not sound too bad, except that it was over three seconds slower than Prost on pole, and 3.002s slower than Senna who had shown what was possible at the limits of the new MP4/8 McLaren. The semi-automatic gearbox then played up as the lights turned green, leaving Andretti as one of three cars left stranded on the line. Eventually his crew got him going a lap down, and although a disastrous way to start one's F1 career, at least it was a chance to explore the car and set some fast laps with no pressure. But after four laps, a concertina effect saw Michael hit the back of Derek Warwick's Footwork, knocking off his front-left wheel and suspension. Even then, it could all be cast aside as simply a troubled weekend to forget, with a fresh start at the next race in Brazil.
After a slow start at Interlagos, Michael progressively found more pace and eventually qualified 5th, less than a second behind Senna in 3rd who himself was in sublime form on home soil. Feeling pleased with himself, he was quickly put back in his place by a no-nonsense Dennis, who greeted him with a terse, "What the hell are you smiling about? You're only 5th." But off the line - and it is worth remembering that standing starts were an equally unfamiliar idea to him - his inexperience showed when he forgot that there was no auto-shift from 1st to 2nd and he had to press the paddle himself. By the time he did this, he was swamped by Karl Wendlinger's Sauber and Berger's fast-starting Ferrari. Wendlinger starting cutting across Andretti's bows, forcing the McLaren to the right into Berger's path. Clipped into a spin by the Ferrari, Michael hit the tyre barrier, the inertia launching the car straight up into the air where it gyrated wildly and almost flipped before landing heavily the right way up. Andretti was taken by helicopter to hospital for observations before being cleared. It had again been more a case of bad luck than bad management, but that pressure was starting to mount. It was not long before the desperation for good results starting turning his natural aggression into regular potential for disaster. At the European GP at Donington, despite another lurid spin coming out of McLeans, he again built up his speed as the weekend progressed, eventually qualifying 6th, just 0.6s behind Senna in 4th. Then in the morning warm-up, he matched his team-mate's time in the wet. But on the first lap, as Senna bullied his way into the lead, Andretti ambitiously, foolishly dived inside Wendlinger, who closed the door, and the inevitable collision put both into the gravel. Three races down, four racing laps completed, and very quickly the raw lack of results overshadowed whether or not things were entirely his fault, particularly when Senna had won two of the first three races and was leading the championship. Perceptions are reality, and this was the time when Andretti needed to be seen to be getting things right. Mechanical and especially electronic software problems that pitched him into spins were attributed to driving errors. The fly-in, fly-out approach then only heightened the sense amongst increasingly-jaundiced crew and critics that he wasn't trying hard enough.
The next race in San Marino was a case in point. Coming out of the last chicane in practice, Andretti rode the kerb, and the active suspension response was to drop the ride height, causing the MP4/8 to bottom out and spin into the pit wall. Senna had spun several times for the same reason, but the attention and criticism was directed at Michael. Then in the race, he was battling Wendlinger once more, this time for 4th, when he spun at the Variante Alta because his rear brakes were starting to lock, and he could not reach the knob to adjust his brake bias in time. Again, it looked like a basic mistake. The European press, always keen to stereotypically take a bite out of an American, were having a field day. In Spain, despite an oversteering car that he qualified over 1.5s slower than Senna, Andretti brought it home in a lapped 5th to record his first points. But it did not stop crazy rumours from circulating that the equally-underperforming Riccardo Patrese at Benetton would either retire or be fired, Nigel Mansell would return from CART to join Benetton, Andretti would resume his seat at Newman-Haas, and Hakkinen would take his race seat at McLaren! Even if that was somewhat beyond the realms of reality, it was true that Dennis was using Hakkinen's presence in the McLaren line-up to his advantage, telling Andretti that he needed to give Mika some track time and that McLaren hadn't signed up the Finn to sit around, in a bid to get Michael to up his game. The last thing Andretti needed was the disaster that befell him at Monaco. A crash in first qualifying in the wet had Michael only 19th fastest, but he climbed to 9th in the dry. But the gearbox at the start caught him out again, as an automatic shift from 1st to 3rd dropped him to nearly the tail of the field. There he hit Fabrizio Barbazza's Minardi at Loew's Hairpin, and the pit stop to change his front wing put him a lap down instantaneously. No-one cared that from there his race pace was solid and he climbed to 8th, the fact was that Senna had won again and Andretti had failed to score again. Likewise in Canada, where a difficult qualifying for the entire McLaren team saw Michael qualify 12th, only half a second behind Ayrton in 8th. In the warm-up, Andretti's alternator failed, and then a flat starter battery on the warm-up lap cost him three laps at the start. An anonymous 14th kept the critics on his back.
In the harsh, harsh world of F1, what in reality was a painful series of events was morphing into good sport watching him fail. And maybe that was the sentiment even from within the team, a team that didn't feel supported by their driver and with an able replacement in the wings. In France, for some reason Andretti's timing beam signal during second qualifying interfered with his auto-downshift, causing him to slide in the corners and leaving him languishing in 16th on the grid, almost 1.5s slower than Senna. In hindsight, Michael called it "a very, very fishy thing". Once again, the damage was done. A storming drive up to a points-paying 6th, with the 7th fastest lap of the race and some excellent cornering speed that was more reminiscent of the CART champion he was, made little positive impression. The fact that in follow-up testing at Magny-Cours he then went 2.5s faster than he had during the race weekend, and was only a tenth off Senna, also went unnoticed. With a higher-specification pneumatic valve engine from Ford at Silverstone, no-one remembers that he dropped four places on the grid when he encountered rain on his quick lap. All people recall is that he qualified only 11th, over 4 seconds off Prost's pole time, and despite a great start he was pushed wide at Copse by Berger and spun lazily into the gravel, race over on the first lap once again. The blur between fact and reality continued at Hockenheim, where once again electronic gremlins cost him in practice. First, he came back to the pits on three wheels at one point when an active suspension malfunction left one wheel locked in the air. Then the gearbox was affected, and once again Andretti was mired in 12th on the grid, almost two seconds slower than Senna. On lap four he clashed with Berger yet again, this time bending his steering arm and putting him out. Dennis summed it up by saying, "Michael made another mistake", which may be true, but was it not fair to also say that had his MP4/8 been reliable in practice then Andretti may not have been battling with Berger at all? Likewise, from 11th on the grid in Hungary he had bolted up to 6th in the early laps, and was comfortably holding off Michael Schumacher who was recovering from a spin when his fly-by-wire throttle failed. In the final reckoning, with other retirements, 2nd was there for his taking.
Justified or not, Dennis was jaded enough by this stage to have decided not to renew Andretti's contract for 1994. Indeed, he was not even going to allow Michael to see out the whole season. He promised to give Hakkinen three races to show his worth, and with Senna having finally committed to the rest of the year, it was clear that Andretti would have to make way at some point, but Ron left the choice of races to the beleaguered American. Michael, understandably feeling decidedly unwelcome, and looking to return to the States, chose to do the next two races and leave F1 as soon as he could. Spa was little better. Despite getting the Series VIII HB engine from Ford, his difficulties coming to grips with this daunting track left him 14th on the grid, and when he stopped for tyres, another electronics glitch cut his engine out when he chose neutral, costing him 30 seconds and leaving him a lapped 8th at the end. Then in Andretti's last hurrah at Monza, he started 9th after yet another troubled practice, spun on lap two at the Roggia chicane, and after stopping for new tyres and to clear the grass from his radiators, he resumed in 20th. But, in an unexpected positive twist of fate, a series of retirements plus a sensational charge, including the 5th fastest lap of the race, saw the American charge back up through the field. He even got past Wendlinger on the track, a vital pass that secured him 3rd place in the end, his best Grand Prix result and his only podium before he made good his decision to turn his back on his F1 experiment and returned to CART. He wound up equal 11th with Wendlinger in the 1993 championship on 7 points, before handing over to Hakkinen - who promptly out-qualified Senna first time out at Estoril. So how does one fairly evaluate Andretti's 1993 season? Any even-handed analysis must start with the machinery and opportunities at his disposal. The McLaren MP4/8 with the underpowered customer Ford engine was not a bad package, but it was no consistent world-beater. Add to that poor electronic reliability, especially on Michael's car, and the lack of testing and practice allowed by the regulators, and it was not uncommon to hear the American saying even after qualifying that he was still learning the circuit. It was hardly possible for Andretti to extract the maximum from the car, let alone transcend it.
In Senna, though, Michael had a team-mate more able than any other to transcend the limits of a car. Ayrton drove the MP4/8 to five wins and 2nd in the title. And in the cold light of day, in a team as used to success as McLaren, it was the harsh reality of results that mattered. Ayrton's brilliance only illuminated Andretti's struggles, whoever's fault it was. And, apart from flashes of real racing nous, Michael did make mistakes, no doubt; often small ones, but regularly, and unfortunately, with glaringly obvious consequences. It was no surprise that Dennis and the press became prejudiced against him. But it was in how he responded to all this that did him no favours. His refusal to relocate even in the face of adversity created the impression, rightly or wrongly, that here was a man so proud, so self-confident that he felt he could just saunter in and get on the pace, but when it was clear that he couldn't, he made no perceivable effort to change, to work harder with the team. If one makes his own luck in F1, Andretti did not help his own cause. Invariably, more glitches, more mistakes would follow. To say that something was a vicious cycle is a cliché, but it certainly applied here. |
||||||||||||||||||||||
| |||
| Back to Reject CENTRALE | |||
| Main Page | Drivers Index | Reject Teams | Hall of Shame | |||
|
Reject Extras Reject Interviews Submit-a-Reject FAQ / Copyright |
Reject CENTRALE Latest GP Review Other Articles Links / Banner |
Sign Guestbook Read Guestbook Current Poll Previous Polls |
|
|
|
|||
| All original content Copyright © 2006 Formula One Rejects. | |||