Be careful what you wish for...

On the publicity trailWaiting for GodotHappy Birthday, Jenson!New boss Briatore

Article written by Liz Shaw

Back to
Reject CENTRALE
Back to
Main Page
Go to
Text-Only Version
Well, how times change. This article was written by one of site's readers back in 2001, and it seems Jenson Button has had the last laugh. Alternatively, perhaps Jenson learned some of the lessons found herein and the resulting improved focus has done wonders for his career. Either way, we keep this article online as a record of what some people (and we remind you, these submitted articles don't necessarily reflect the views of F1 Rejects, then or now!) were thinking about Mr Button back in mid-2001. JMcG, 16-Oct-2004.

There's an old saying that goes: Be careful what you wish for ... you just might get it. As a prime example of this, may I submit as Exhibit 'A', Mr. Jenson Button, late of Williams Grand Prix, presently of Benetton Renault, soon of history.


WHATEVER HAPPENED TO JENSON BUTTON?

Last year Mr. Button was touted as Britain's Next World Driving Champion; this year, in lesser equipment, he's another backmarker fighting the second Minardi for 20th place on the grid. And not always winning even that fight, much less the fight against his teammate in equally suspect equipment. What went wrong since Button left Williams? Has he forgotten how to drive? Have the pressures of the spotlight caused him to lose his way? Or could it be that Button has in fact reached exactly the goal he set?

I've spent the last few days diligently reading the History of Jenson Button's F1 Career (all 18 months of it) in Autosport magazine, which could have easily been subtitled The Jenson Button Magazine of Record, such a wealth of material did it provide me. At first I was inclined to accept the "too much, too soon" hypothesis; after all, the boy was only 19 when he got his drive at Williams (narrowly beating out Bruno Junqueira due, I would venture to guess, mainly to a fluke rainstorm that caused Bruno to take his test on a wet track and allowed Button to take his on a dry one).

Bar Kimi Raikkonen and Fernando Alonso, that is certainly a tender age to be pitchforked into the top level of motorsport and expected to perform with professionals several years your senior. But then by chance, on the back of one of the Button pieces, I came across a one-page article in which Rubens Barrichello discussed his own entry into Formula One at the age of 20, and in contrasting the two young men I found what I believe is my answer.


Cool, suave, stylish. Britain's great new hope takes some time out for a glamourous photoshoot. Cool, suave, stylish. Britain's great new hope takes some time out for a glamourous photoshoot.

Rubens came into Formula One in 1993, a very young and very promising Brazilian in the shadow of the great Ayrton Senna. He was 21 years old on the weekend in 1994 when, as Niki Lauda phrased it, "God lifted his hand from Formula One." Rubens was the first to suffer a massive accident that weekend, and the only one of three to survive; Roland Ratzenberger was killed on the Saturday and Senna on the Sunday. In thoughtful hindsight Rubens comments that Senna's was the first funeral he had ever attended, and that he "had a hard time believing he was in that box." It was only after he returned with the Formula One circus to race in Brazil that he realised that Senna was indeed gone from among them, and that the collective eyes of Brazil were now on him in full expectation that he step up and take his countryman's place on the grid.

"And then," says Rubens candidly, "I went crazy." He ended up breaking his heart and probably damaging his career in the earnest and doomed effort to fulfil his country's expectations of him, but with the wise counsel of his father he realised that "you can't be 40 years old at 20" and that it was in fact his own responsibility to decide what his goal was to be and how he would reach it. So, at a very young age, Rubens with even worse pressure than Button had, determined that his goal was not to become Senna, but to be the best racing driver he could possibly be. And within his abilities and with the opportunities he's had, he has got what he wished for. It seems to me that Jenson Button has interpreted the pressure from his countrymen in quite a different way.


Jenson Button takes a look at his first pay check of 2000, and can't believe his luck!Jenson Button takes a look at his first pay check of 2000, and can't believe his luck!

That is, he has interpreted the tremendous media interest as being in him personally, not in Britain's hopes for him on the track, and he has become a celebrity - that is, a famous person whose fame is derived from the fact that he drives a racing car. And because of the unexpectedly good car Williams gave him, the earnest desire of his team and the public to see him succeed (and thus to forgive him those errors he made in learning his craft); and taking advantage of the fact that his predecessor, one Alessandro Zanardi, had made a less than sterling impression the year before (in a pig of a car) Button was able to produce enough sizzle on the track to content people generally. But it was already obvious that he viewed the craft of race driver in quite a different way from that of other successful pilots his age.

A telling quote from a friend that the best part about Button's contract with Williams was "Now you'll be on the new game for Playstation II!" is the first hint where his heart really is: in merchandising. From the first day he began to drive for Williams, Button concentrated all his real attention on giving the media the darling he believed it really wanted. At first the stories celebrate him as "just one of the guys", quoting him as saying he would never change - he loved his home in England, he loved his girlfriend, he loved British automobiles, and gee whiz, isn't it great that all you people want to put me on chat shows and on the radio, talk to me for the papers and wow, I'm getting to be in Autosport with all my heroes....


Jenson his the media publicity trail just after getting his Wiliams drive, appearing on British chat shows. Jenson his the media publicity trail just after getting his Wiliams drive, appearing on British chat shows.

Then it starts going to his head. Before we know it, he's bought a Ferrari, bought a flat in Monaco, and his now ex-girlfriend Kimberley Keay is giving interviews to the tabloids detailing how he got her pregnant and kicked her out to fend for herself; Jenson himself is silent on this subject, but his father (!) is quoted as saying Jenson is "Auditioning" for a new girlfriend, and is using among his pickup lines, "I'm going to Monaco to look at flats, want to come?", an attitude far more suitable for an ageing roué or a lottery winner than for a boy who has just reached the top of his profession and has his work cut out to remain there. Before he has actually signed a contract with Williams Grand Prix, in rapid succession Button reveals that he is writing his autobiography (at the age of 19!) and considering the endorsement of a personally-branded line of clothing. He is appearing on television and radio and in print, and almost always the stories concentrate on what he is buying and who he is dating (currently would-be singer Louise Griffiths). His time on the track is just another way in which he entertains us, not his life's work, far less his vocation.

As long as I was considering Button solely in his role as second driver at Williams Grand Prix, I found this attitude very hard to understand, especially in light of the fact that, from the day he was hired, it was common knowledge that he was only in that seat until Sir Frank Williams could find a way to bring Juan Pablo Montoya back from Champ Cars in America, unless Button proved himself the better pilot. And Juan Pablo Montoya was certainly proving himself as a racing driver, not by his antics in the press, but by winning everything on offer B on short ovals, superspeedways, street courses and road courses, including the Indianapolis 500. Juan Pablo was a man whose vocation is racing, with obvious natural talent and the driving flair last seen in one Gilles Villeneuve. And Juan Pablo Montoya knew what his goal was and how he was going to reach it. "I am here," he said over and over, "to drive the car and win for the team."


Out with the old, in with the new. Dumped was Kim Keay (below) and JB went apartment hunting in Monaco with Louise Griffiths (right).

Kimberley Keay

Having a good time with his new flame, Louise Griffiths.

That was the bit Mr. Button seemed to have forgotten about, and it puzzled me that this statement and the clear demonstration of proof that he could do it, in his biggest rival, rang no alarm bells in Jenson's mind. There is plenty of evidence that the contrast between the two men was not escaping the Supremos at Williams Grand Prix, either. It is well known that to Williams Grand Prix, the cars and the team have always been far more important than the pilots, and had Button been paying attention he would have heard some pretty strong evidence that his position as "media darling" was not sitting well with his bosses. Patrick Head was quoted in Autosport comparing Button and his entourage and attitude to a Spice Girl - those dressed-up dollies whose talent, if any, was sustained and augmented by the technology and PR that surrounded them; hardly a flattering comparison to most serious racing pilots, but Button apparently paid it no mind.

On many occasions the comments came, from Gerhard Berger of BMW as well as from Head and Sir Frank, that perhaps there was too much being written and discussed about Jenson the Playboy and not enough Jenson the Racing Driver, that perhaps he was not taking his work seriously enough ... and the negotiations to bring Montoya back from Champ Cars grew more intense. At first it is said that Montoya will join the team in the 2002 season when his Champ Car contract is up. Suddenly the stories are about how this contract can be bought out and Montoya brought to Williams for 2001. But even with word that an announcement would be made in September at the United States Grand Prix that the deal had been done, Button continues on the course he has set. Surely this should have started alarm bells ringing. But no. Button's results on the track were just good enough to keep his celebrity alive, but nowhere near as good as Montoya's; perhaps he really did believe that somehow the whole Montoya thing was just going to go away, because he did nothing to raise his game.


Button has a good read of the newspaper; an article about himself, perhaps?Button has a good read of the newspaper; an article about himself, perhaps?

But as we know, "the Montoya thing" didn't go away, and in 2001 Button was assigned to Benetton and Montoya was installed at Williams. (Button took consolation in Ralf Schumacher's statements that he would have preferred to keep Button as a teammate to the unknown quantity Montoya. It is interesting to note that on January 20, 2000, Schumacher was quoted in Autosport using almost exactly the same words about his desire to keep Alessandro Zanardi rather than taking on the unknown quantity Jenson Button.) Talk about a reality check! Suddenly all the talk about a World Driving Championship in two years' time was silenced, as Britain's Great Hope was revealed to be inexperienced boy who couldn't handle a bad car, didn't seem to be able to help develop that car, and spent all his time at the back of the grid fighting with the second Minardi to keep from qualifying last.

To an extent this must be blamed on the car, which is something of an anvil to drive; yet it can't be denied that in equal equipment his teammate is consistently as much as four seconds quicker and has put his car in the points, which Button has not come close to doing in any race this season. And has he learned from this to concentrate on his work and keep from slipping farther down the grid to the ignominy of a testing position next year, if anything? He has not. He has added to his long list of toys a 71-foot yacht, and the formerly fawning press said scathingly, that the berth in Monaco close to Pit Out was "as close to the front of the grid as Button will ever get." Stories are written suggesting that perhaps a guy whose career is slipping away from him should not spend so much time playing about on yachts and having his picture taken on deck with girls; Button's response is "I'm a young guy, what am I supposed to do, stay home and read Shakespeare?"


Jenson ecstatic over his latest purchase, a 71-foot floating bachelor pad, anchored among those of the rich and famous. To glitz or not to glitz, that is the question, eh Jense?Jenson exstatic over his latest purchase, a 71-foot floating bachelor pad, anchored among other toy-things of the rich and glitzy.

And finally comes the bizarre spectacle of Jenson's father and his manager publicly vilifying Montoya to anyone who will listen, bluntly calling him "stupid" and "hopeless" and coming perilously close to questioning Sir Frank's sanity in preferring him to their client/son. To me this sounds very much like an overprotective parent screaming that the other kid took his son's lollipop, and it is unprofessional in the extreme if the parent and manager are doing it on their own hook, which leads me to believe they are doing it so Jenson can maintain plausible deniability. But I have no doubt the words are his, and that he still fondly believes that in racing, as in everything else he has gained through his fame as a racing driver, all you have to do is scream "I want it!" and lo and behold, it's yours. It took me some time to figure out why Button has missed not only all the hints, but the bat over the head of losing his Williams seat after less than a year and being sent to the back of the grid - why he continues on the course that has served him so ill, in defiance of common sense.

And then it hit me. I was mistaken in the goal that Jenson Button set himself. I had assumed that his ambition was to fulfil the hope of his countrymen for the Next British Driving Champion - or at the least, as Rubens Barrichello has done, to become the best pilot he is capable of being. But I was wrong. Somewhere along the line, it seems that Button has decided to grasp the package and not the gift within; his ambition was not to perfect his vocation on the track, but for the money and fame that, if one is fortunate, attend upon that perfection. In my opinion he chose the wrong end of the stick to grasp: he never figured out that he wasn't hired to be a celebrity who drives a racing car, but a racing driver who might, if he were lucky, have become a celebrity.


Jenson Button, therefore, is not a star; he is a meteor that streaked briefly across the skies of Formula One and left a bright trail that is already fading - because he fell foul of the prime directive of the universe.

He wasn't careful what he wished for. And he got his wish.

Article written by Liz Shaw © 2001
California, U.S.A.


F1 Rejects
Back to Reject CENTRALE
Main Page   |    Drivers Index   |   Reject Teams   |   Hall of Shame
Featured Rejects
Reject Statistics
Submit-a-Reject
FAQ / Copyright
Reject CENTRALE
• Latest GP Review
• Other Articles
• Links / Banner
Sign Guestbook
Read Guestbook
Current Poll
Previous Polls
Please send any corrections, comments or suggestions to
centrale@f1rejects.com
All original content Copyright © 2001 Formula One Rejects.